The necessity for iterative improvement and updating to antimicrobial and odor control standard test methods, such as AATCC TM 100 and ASTM E2149, cannot and should not be understated. These updates ensure that the test methods that we rely on are evaluated against real-world conditions, are scientifically sound, and continue to improve the safety, efficacy, and sustainability of treated articles, now and in the future.

Why Updating Test Methods is Essential
Test methods like AATCC TM 100 and ASTM E2149 have long been recognized and utilized across industries, but the utility of a test method is maintained through iterative improvement. Through iterative improvements, test methods can more accurately evaluate how antimicrobial and odor control technologies perform in real-world conditions. Updating these methods is not just about maintaining relevance; it’s about ensuring that the results are robust, reproducible, and reflective of the actual consumer experience. This iterative process of refining test methods is a hallmark of sound science—one that prioritizes improvements and eliminates negative impacts, such as overstatements regarding the efficacy of a product or technology and unforeseen environmental impacts.

The Value of Improved Testing for the entire Product Value Chain
Up-to-date test methods offer significant benefits across the entire product value chain. For brands and retailers, these updates provide a stronger scientific basis for marketing claims, boosting consumer confidence, achieving sustainability goals, and helping companies adhere to regulatory requirements. Mills and manufacturers benefit from clearer guidance on technology performance, worker and environmental safety, reducing wasted resources and supporting more efficient production processes. For consumers, improved and up-to-date test methods ensures that the products they purchase are not only effective but also safe and sustainable. Importantly, for the environment, these enhancements help to limit the unintended consequences of antimicrobial treatments by ensuring that products perform as claimed, minimizing unnecessary chemical use, and reducing the potential for harm to aquatic ecosystems.

The Scientific Process is a Sound Process
Iterative updates to a test method can take years due to the meticulous nature of the scientific process. Each step requires rigorous experimentation, data collection, studies, cross laboratory studies, and validation to ensure that proposed changes truly enhance the method's accuracy and relevance. This methodical approach prevents rushed decisions that could lead to unreliable results or unforeseen consequences. The process often involves multiple rounds of peer review, industry collaboration, and can even include regulatory consultation, ensuring that updates are scientifically sound and beneficial for all stakeholders. While slow, this thoroughness builds confidence in the results and minimizes risks and negative impacts.

Related Articles